|
The
Education of Young Muslims in the UK
Islamic
Educational Needs
and Possibilities in the UK Educational Context
Bismillahirrahmanirrahim
INTRODUCTION
Salaamu
aleikum
I
should begin by saying that the compression required to fit
the topic of this paper into a twenty minute talk is a serious
impossibility, hence this document which I hope may be useful
for reading and discussion.
Two
years ago, I gave a short talk to a group of non-muslims, in
which I tried to summarise the muslim criticisms of the
secular system, and the alternative muslim understanding of
education. This was in the main excerpted from one book in the
series issuing from the First World Conference on Muslim
education at King Abdulaziz University, `The Aims and
Objectives of Islamic Education' by Syed Muhammad al-Naquib
al-Attas, and I will begin with a transcript of part of that
talk, and follow it with considerations more specific to a
muslim audience, and particularly those muslims for whom this
paper was prepared.
CRISIS IN WESTERN EDUCATION
"At
the moment we have a crisis in our secular/humanist so-called
education system, not just for the children of believers, but
for all of western civilization. When rational man discarded
his faith he lost touch with an essential element of what is
required to truly educate a man - values.
There
is a difference between education and instruction. Education
helps in the complete growth of an individual personality,
whereas instruction is training to do some mental or physical
task efficiently. A man may be a fine doctor or lawyer,
engineer or accountant, and still be ill mannered, unjust,
amoral, cruel, dissatisfied, unhappy, and obviously only
partially educated.
When
we see an educated man what we recognise is his
"goodness". A `good' man does not mean a `complete'
man, as there is no end to human growth throughout a life, so
an educated man is outward looking, modifying his
understanding and behaviour as his life is enriched with
knowledge and experience. This knowledge and experience, as
well as the basic values and assumptions on which it is based,
man learns from the society that surrounds him. He is an
individual and part of a structured community, and both are
necessary to the survival of each other, as unfettered
individualism means anarchy and the breakdown of all systems,
whereas excessive social control leads to stagnation,
degeneration, and violent social upheaval (as what is rigid
shatters like glass, rather than bending like steel).
Education
preserves societal structures, conserving basic values and
understandings, and transmitting them to the next generation,
while at the same time looking to the reality of human needs
and interests in all their variety, by nurturing personal
growth, helping man to satisfy his yearning for a quality of
life through the understanding of fundamental values. A
quality of life which satisfies man's yearnings on many
different levels. How you understand this quality of life,
this aim of education, is basic to the way your education
system works.
BASES OF WESTERN EDUCATION SYSTEMS & FAILURE OF SECULARISM
At
present we have three main approaches, the Secular-modernist,
the humanist, and the religious.
Secular
modernists do not distinguish between education and
instruction, regarding education not as a conserver of human
values, but as a process of change and a venture into the
unknown. Organization of new knowledge is more important than
the preservation of knowledge. They see education as a process
that helps man to live well in this material world, and don't
believe in fundamental, unchangeable, moral or spiritual
values.
Humanists
do accept that there are some kinds of underlying values, but
believe that these value concepts are the result of man's own
rationality. They see education as the mental, emotional, and
moral development, that comes from helping man to see
different points of view, and the relationship of these points
of view to one another. It means the rejection of dogma, the
questioning of absolutes, and the reliance on reason.
Here
they hit some major problems, however, as there are a number
of areas of human life which seem highly resistant to
rationality, matters involving faith.
Thus
despite their apparent freedom, (the freedom to challenge
accepted knowledge) both secular modernism and humanism place
man in the prison of his own rationality.
Religion,
on the other hand, places man in a very large perspective -
the perspective of infinity and eternity. Man partakes of
these through his spirit, which is alone regarded as the
custodian of eternal truth.
Religion
provides an all-comprehensive norm for man and an
all-inclusive goal for his education. The norm has stability
because basic values are regarded as absolutes derived from
the absolute attributes of God, which are continually being
realised in time and space. In different times and places
there will be changes in emphasis and focus. There will be the
modification of relative importance of certain values, or the
way they are expressed, but that does not mean a change in the
values themselves.
Religion
thus provides a meaningful goal for education, a goal which is
revealed, not just derived from man's experience. Yet man's
collective experience would seem to verify the superiority of
the religious experience as a model. We may still be able to
see the material remains of the Pharaohs and the Caesars,
marks carved and left for history like initials on a tree, but
the men whom the majority of humanity have taken as models on
which to shape their lives -Moses, Jesus, Muhammad, can be
seen not frozen in golden images or marble statues, but alive
and present in the actions of their true followers.
ISLAMIC EDUCATION - AN INTEGRATED SYSTEM
The
aim of muslim education is the creation of "the good and
righteous man" whose purpose is to worship God in the
full Islamic meaning of the word, and build up the structure
of his earthly life according to the laws required of God's
creation.
Worship
in Islam is not restricted to performance of rituals, but
embraces all man's activity - faith, thought, feeling, and
work, and to give man the tools to carry out this purpose,
worship, his education must achieve two things. It must enable
man to understand his Lord, and it must enable man to
understand creation.
Islam
makes this goal something balanced and comprehensive. Man is
regarded as the vicegerent
of God on earth. God has given man
authority over creation, and in order to realise this
authority in actual life man must acquire wisdom, which
transforms him into a good man, and turns him into a wise
master. It is therefore a comprehensive process, training
emotional, intellectual, and sensual faculties simultaneously.
God has revealed to man his nature, and the laws that lead man
to the complete flowering of his personality. Man is expected
to learn through experiments and work out the details of the
process whose broad foundations are given to man in the Qur'an
and whose human example was seen in the life activities and
sayings of His messenger Muhammad.
Thus
Islam has a supreme ideal and an unshakable norm for
educationists to aim at when working out education systems and
methodology. These normative values save man from vague
humanist secularist drifting, yet these universal norms are
eminently compatible with rationality. It provides the concept
of One God, one humanity, and one religion from the days of
Adam, the norm of human values being considered to be the same
for all humanity in all ages.
It
teaches man humility by showing him that all power over Nature
or himself is power delegated to him by God. It is not his
own. This leads to a better understanding of others and
happiness among nations and races.
Last
but not least, the framework of values depends on the concept
of faith in the hereafter. Man is to consider this life not as
an end in itself, but as a process leading to a complete and
better life in the hereafter, cultivating acceptance of faith
and action according to a revealed norm.
In
order that action
may lead to the betterment of man and society, a methodology
of self-analysis and social criticism is taught which
generates sensitive individuals aware of rights, duties, and
responsibilities, and conscious of their own shortcomings.
Love
of God and the Prophet are the major means of acquiring this
sensitivity necessary to balance the purely intellectual.
Science and values are made to play complementary roles, with
values providing guidance and aims. This is far more
satisfying than the dry intellectualism of humanism because it
gives cardinal importance to love, and hence to
human
sensibilities." (M.A.M. February 1988)
"Modern
educational theories and practices indicate that the functions
of the school as a social organization can be summed up as:
transmitting heritage and shaping it to suit the needs of the
day; and self-actualization of the individual, who is the
nucleus of the society, so that he may utilize his talents and
capabilities in the service of his society by improving his
educational, social and material status. The individual can
thus participate to the full in his responsibilities as a
citizen (which include cooperation with other citizens,
loyalty to the authorities, as well as protection of public
property and defence of the country)" S.A.Abu
Aali - Islamic Education: A Means Towards Self-Actualization
(from Curriculum and Teacher Education ed.M.H.Al-Afendi &
N.A.Baloch)
So
we can understand Islamic Education as an integrated system,
but we must consider how we can achieve this for young muslims
being educated in the UK system. There would seem to be two
approaches that can be taken, separation or conversion, and as
conversion may seem unattainable to some I will begin with
considerations of a separate Islamic Education system.
A SEPARATE ISLAMIC EDUCATION SYSTEM
It
is clear that an independent muslim school will still need to
be capable of integrating its education with that of the state
system for a number of reasons. There are practical reasons,
such as children changing schools when their families change
their circumstances and need to move home. There is the need
for children to compete on re-entry into the system if the
muslim school does not provide continuous education through
all school ages, or at college or university level, presuming
that we will not be building Islamic Universities here for
some time at least. Then there are the legal reasons of
needing to comply with state curricular requirements.
National
tendencies in curriculum matters highlight problems of
integration, however, problems coming not so much from the
system as from a muslim intellectual malaise. In the present
political climate, there is really no barrier to muslims
opening a school or becoming governors, it is more a case of
what do you do after you've got that far. What model of an
Educational system are we to suggest or offer as a replacement
for what is there? It is clear that the education systems
current in muslim countries do not approach the high ideals of
Islamic Educational theory, let alone qualify for use in the
UK context.
CRISIS IN MUSLIM EDUCATION
To
deal with the problem it is essential to face up to the clear
failure of the present Muslim Education system to educate and
strengthen the faith of its pupils and the community. The
mosques are used by only a tiny fraction of the nominally
muslim community, and when muslim children turn into muslim
youth and grow beyond the stage of compulsory visits to the
mosque, they are rapidly lost and Islam soon becomes as
irrelevant to most youth as it is to their parents.
A
survey of muslim families shows many young muslims consider
Islam to be completely unintelligible. They still become
teachers or doctors or engineers, so they are not necessarily
stupid, yet it seems that they are interested in some of their
education, but not in any aspect of Islam.
"When
we talk about religious education, the formal and the
traditional lessons on religion immediately come to mind. And
even if our imagination flew beyond the normal limits of the
rigid religious lesson, it would seize on a sermon or a
religious speech, not more, and there it would come to a halt.
We do not, in fact, impart education in our schools,
particularly Islamic education.
"If
the schools set up in most parts of the Muslim world are
reluctant to carry out religious education, or if they are
willing to adopt it but do not know how, the final result is
the same in either case - we do not, in actual fact, bring our
children up according to the ideals of true Islamic education.
The impact of the genuine Islamic spirit on our school
curricula is hardly noticeable. We ought to consider, however,
that a formal and traditional lesson on religion will not be
sufficient to meet the desired human requirements,
particularly in contemporary life. An overdose of a religious
speech or sermon would, instead of rendering religion
pleasant, interesting and likeable, create a repellent and
damaging effect .................... Religion as we feel and
approach it now, has dwindled from the integrated
inclusiveness known to earlier Muslim generations into
something more or less akin to the Western ecclesiastical
approach, namely, an emotional relationship between Lord and
servant outside the sphere of actual life. This fact, which we
ought to acknowledge frankly and unequivocally if we are to
deal with our subject honestly and seriously, casts its thick
and impenetrable shadow over our entire lives; besides, it is
closely relevant to education curricula." Muhammad
Qutb - The Role of Religion in Education (from Aims and
Objectives of Islamic Education ed.S.N.Al-Attas)
What
the present system of muslim education produces is an
education not to be treasured but to be discarded, and anyone
considering starting a new muslim school should seriously
consider whether more of the same is likely to produce any
better results. It would seem that the problem is the
inevitable result of the lack of a fully integrated curriculum
and the inadequacy of the partial education provided in most
mosques and schools in most muslim countries as well as the
UK.
"Islamic
education .............. fluctuated in periods of prosperity
and periods of decline, the latter being caused by the
weakening of spiritual values, the disintegration of the
Islamic Ummah, political and military disorders, and the
weakening of the social and economic structure in most Muslim
countries.
A
number of factors brought about educational decay, the painful
repercussions of which are being felt to this day:
(i)
The Muslim mind lapsed into inertia and dropped creativity for
imitation, and the substance for ephemeral appearances and
style. In some Muslim countries, the purpose of education
became the learning of texts by heart whether understood or
not. Learners became content with the repetition of what older
scholars had said, and confined their interest to interpreting
a limited number of books and adding comments in the margins.
Original and profound thought became rare, and very few would
devote time to discovering the mysteries of nature or the laws
of society which would contribute to its solidarity and
prosperity, and which would help to disseminate the Islamic
spirit and foster continued progress.
(ii)
Another factor was the failure to promote technical and
scientific knowledge although it flourished at one time in the
Muslim world, and the renunciation of the branches of
knowledge which were formerly studied by the Muslims, such as
medicine, mathematics, chemistry and astronomy, on the
erroneous assumption that they would lead to scepticism,
uncertainty and unbelief.
(iii)
Failure to educate women in a planned and regular manner as
required by Islam.
(iv)
Colonization...........................
If
Islamic education is to revive and resume the role it played
in the past, it will have to reconsider the way teachers are
trained and qualified, to infuse a religious spirit into every
subject and course, to adopt suitable Islamic teaching
methods, to organize student brotherhoods, to acquire the
necessary techniques and skills for the advancement of
society, to foster spiritual and moral values among both
teachers and students, and to fill their hearts with the love
of God and reliance on His support to serve Islam and
humanity." A.H.Khaldun
Kinnany - Producing Teachers for Islamic Education (from
Curriculum and Teacher Education ed.M.H.Al-Afendi &
N.A.Baloch)
WHAT IS MISSING?
Firstly,
a Curriculum and Educational Material, though one often gets
the impression that many muslims consider both unnecessary.
But it is hard to run an educational establishment of any kind
if what is required to be taught is not defined. A curriculum
lays out the educational requirements to teach a system of
thought, defining its principles, aims, objectives etc. As the
Scottish Education System is the specific subject of a
separate paper I will avoid it, but to draw examples from the
UK system I will make use of recent research into the English
National Curriculum with excerpts from Curriculum Matters
documents recently produced by Her Majesty's Inspectorate for
the Department of Education and Science.
THE NATIONAL CURRICULUM - DEFINED OBJECTIVES
The
White Paper `Better Schools' (1985) suggested that what
children learn between the ages of 5 and 16 should help them,
among other things, to develop lively, enquiring minds; use
language effectively; develop tolerance of other races,
religions and ways of life; understand the world in which they
live; and appreciate human achievements and aspirations.
HMI
in Curriculum Matters 2 identify nine areas of learning and
experience which will need to be used as a general framework
throughout the full range of educational subjects. These are:
aesthetic and creative; human and social; linguistic and
literary; mathematical; moral; physical; scientific;
spiritual; and technological.
"In
particular, consideration should be given to the following
qualities:
a)
Work habits: imaginative, creative, flexible; systematic;
independent in thought and action; cooperative; persistent.
b)
Attitudes: fascination with the subject;
interest and motivation; pleasure and enjoyment from
........ activities; appreciation of the purpose, power and
relevance of (the subject); satisfaction derived from a sense
of achievement; confidence in an ability to (work) at an
appropriate level.
"But
whatever the approach and whatever the age of the pupils there
are two main reasons for studying (a subject): its intrinsic
interest, and its capacity to increase pupils' understanding
of themselves and of the world in which they live."
"A
well-conceived course ............ should not only pay
scrupulous attention to objectivity and avoid political bias -
it will, by its very nature, give young people the means to
identify and resist indoctrination."
"To
avoid bias and indoctrination it is necessary for young people
to acquire an informed and critical understanding of all the
views held about ....... issues"
Education
"should kindle their imagination, stimulate an informed personal
response and demand rigour and precision - in observation and
recording, in the analysis of linguistic features and the
abstraction of information, and in the disciplined application
of ....... judgement."
Pupils
should "develop a European awareness through an understanding of their
cultural and linguistic heritage; develop tolerant but not
uncritical attitudes towards customs and practices unlike
their own; develop ............ powers of observation,
abstraction and analysis of information, judgement and
communication."
"As
a general rule no result .......... should be accepted
uncritically without asking whether it is a reasonable
statement to make in the context of the question."
"The
primary objective is not to attempt to dictate ideal solutions
but for pupils to be in command of a range of knowledge and
understanding so that they can order priorities, predict some
of the likely consequences of decisions being made and begin
to develop self-confidence in dealing with challenging
situations."
SYSTEMS
The
education systems of England and Scotland are pupil-centred
teaching systems, following pupils' inclinations and
preferences, and using this interest to teach them how they
can educate themselves in all other areas. A subtle
understanding of the difference between systems and content
and the way they interreact is essential if we are to pick our
way through the Islamicization of western education systems.
For example, we have heard a great deal concerning muslim
girls in France where they were refused entry to their school
due to the wearing of hijab. In a situation where a muslim
school chooses to define a form of hijab and enforce it on
girls who do not wish to wear it, that school is following an
identical system of a compulsory dress-code based on different
normative judgements, not a different Islamic way in which
perhaps there is no compulsion.
It
is to be hoped that when considering an educational system,
muslims conservative tendencies would not lead them to utilize
only the most outdated of educational systems while those
whose system they copy are in the process of discarding it for
something better. Islamic education must use the most advanced
systems of conceptualization, communication and knowledge
processing, otherwise muslim pupils will inevitably remain
disadvantaged. In fact, when examining the traditions of
Islamic Education, we often find that such concepts as pupil-centred
education have been around a long time.
"There
are certain truisms about education, regarded as a cultural
process, which it is necessary to
recall....................First of these is that we must
educate our students in such a manner that they acquire the
capacity to educate themselves for the rest of their
lives." A.K.Brohi
- Education in an Ideological State (from Aims and Objectives
of Islamic Education ed.S.N.Al-Attas)
EXISTING AND FUTURE TEACHING PRINCIPLES IN UK
Other
extracts from National Curriculum documents remind that "The
aim that pupils should learn to work in a systematic way does
not clash with the aim that they should learn to show
imagination, initiative and flexibility of mind; the two aims
are complementary."
Education
should "kindle their imagination ........ and stimulate a personal
response; develop an open and sympathetic attitude towards the
........ unfamiliar; develop a critical and reflective
understanding of the world in which they live;"
Islam
is rarely seen to be taught this way and such thinking is
discouraged. Teachers traditionally tend to enforce rote
learning with no concern for understanding, and prefer
acceptance and repetition of dogma without question rather
than curiosity, and the challenge of the unfamiliar.
HMI
suggests that Education should be "an
experience from which pupils derive pleasure and
enjoyment." Can we imagine Islam being taught this
way?
This
is the root of the problem, an inability to communicate across
that conceptual divide, and incidentally, the reason for a
complete lack of da'wah (communication of the Islamic message)
in the West. This is the schizophrenic edge on which muslim
children live, constantly switching between two opposite
systems they choose the one they prefer and forget the other.
As long as Islam is taught by means of a different conceptual
system to the rest of a child's education and surrounding
culture, children will suffer from the conflict.
"It
is difficult to resolve this conflict if the traditional
religious attitude is either discarded or ignored in favour of
the empirical, because this will magnify conflicts and lead
possibly to further bloodshed. Those disciplined in the old
system and not fully aware of the complexities of modern
civilization, and those disciplined in the new system who have
never cared to appreciate their own heritage, can never come
together or resolve the conflict. All attempts in the past
have proved false and hypocritical. The traditionalists either
exploited the name of religion for irreligious purposes or
were exploited by the modernists for their own secular ends.
What is therefore necessary is the emergence of a third group
who are acquainted with their own traditions but are willing
to acquire any wisdom that modern civilization can offer. Only
then will it be possible for a modern Muslim to integrate the
principles of moral and spiritual behaviour with current
intellectual knowledge. ................. People belonging to
this third group, however, are still to a large extent
disjointed and extremely limited in number. As they have to
work within the context of modern life, they have to
`reconstruct' protective philosophical and theological systems
and reinterpret religious thought in terms of modern life.
.............. Only by doing this will they be able to save
modern Muslims from the tension and insecurity in which they
are living today."
"Unless
an attempt is made now to Islamicize the humanities, social,
and natural sciences by producing basic concepts and by
changing the methodology of approaching them or teaching them,
it will not be possible to create a viable group
intellectually capable of resisting the onslaught of
secularist teaching." Crisis
in Muslim Education - Syed Ali Ashraf & Syed Sajjad Husain
IS IT POSSIBLE TO TEACH ISLAM THIS WAY?
"Training
in the mosque university was a combined activity in which both
student and teacher took part. The student had to be persuaded
rather than instructed and the teacher had to argue his case
rather than dictate it. In this way the personality and the
intellectual ability of the student was allowed to develop and
grow..........traditional Islamic education measured its
activity by the fact that it stimulated the community as a
whole to take an interest in the higher issues so fundamental
to its nature and survival."
Traditional Islamic Education: Its Aims and Purposes - Zaki
Badawi (from Aims and Objectives of Islamic Education
ed.S.N.Al-Attas)
"
Islamic education must build into the minds of Muslim youth a
resilience, an adaptability and a mechanism for adjustment in
worldly matters other than fundamental beliefs. The Arabs were
the first people to demonstrate such a resilience and
adaptability during the heyday of Islamic intellectual
effervescence. They acquired the Greek learning, subjected it
to investigation, experimentation and expansion in such
diverse fields as algebra, geometry, astronomy, navigation,
chemistry and medicine and evolved the scientific principles
of empiricism. The essence of empirical scientific attitude
consisted of moving away from dogmatic beliefs and practices
in worldly matters and raising healthy doubts about all
propositions. By questioning everything that could be
questioned, by asking at every step: `is that so?' this
empirical attitude gave immense freedom to human curiosity and
became the cause of major scientific discoveries. Scientific
beliefs came to be held tentatively rather than dogmatically,
in the hope that further investigation and experimentation
would lead to alternative beliefs. The Arabs carried this new
empirical scientific attitude to Spain among other places and
from there this attitude burst out into Europe in the
fifteenth and sixteenth centuries and caused the Renaissance.
The
Islamic education system must now adopt the same scientific
empiricism in worldly matters which the Muslims had themselves
invented but had forgotten during the past five centuries. The
values of adaptability, experimentation, and tolerance (as
opposed to dogma) must be embodied in the new system. This
will, in all probability require the institution of ijtihad or
interpretation of the Islamic law..............The new
educational system must be an integrating force and must
prepare men for ijtihad where it is due."
Dr.A.M.Khusro - Education in the Islamic Society
WHAT IS NECESSARY TO TEACH ISLAM THIS WAY
Apart
from an established curriculum, the essential requirements
would seem to be three: Educational Materials (including
source texts); Suitable Teachers; and Parent Education.
i)
Educational Materials: Much of the difficulty of introducing
Islamic aspects of knowledge into the present system is due
not to lack of will, but lack of Educational Materials on
which to base a class.
"In
many schools the study of traditional patterns, such as those
associated with the Islamic faith, led to the analysis of
their symmetry and form, and an appreciation of their
mathematical elegance. Nevertheless, teachers often expressed
concern at the general lack of resources available to support
the multicultural aspects of primary mathematics; a factor
which frustrated their wish to do more."
[PRIMARY EDUCATION - THE TEACHING AND LEARNING OF MATHEMATICS
(HMI/DES)]
In
any muslim school, this lack of material will also make the
task extremely difficult, despite the finest of intentions.
Before
any reasonable education can be given, Source Texts, Text
Books and Resource materials for the different subjects will
need to be produced. At the moment, these hardly exist in
English, and this is not just true of the school I just
quoted, as the sum total of all the English language books in
all Glasgow's mosque libraries is pathetically inadequate, let
alone sufficient to the task of providing the resources for a
reasonable Islamic education. Some individual authors have
written more books.
But
usable books in good English are rare, and more need to be
written. Good translations of Source material are even rarer,
so requirements need to be outlined and translations made.
Resource materials are unco-ordinated or non-existent, and
these will have to be created to suit the system. Computer
programmes, Educational Games, and suchlike will all need to
be prepared.
ii)
Teachers trained in system: These will have to be
knowledgeable in the Islamic background to their subject, at
ease in the surrounding culture, and committed to living in
it, as a foundation for involvement in the establishment of
the system and training within it.
iii)
Parental Education: A major part of a children's Islamic
education comes from their parents in the home. For the school
to successfully function as the educational centre for the
community, it would seem necessary for parents not only to
involve themselves in the running of the school, but actively
participate in a course of self-education in order to
understand more fully the principles involved in the teaching.
OTHER ISSUES
Priorities:
When
considering the good of the whole community, it is important
to consider matters of priorities, and consider whether we can
ensure that the advantage of the few does not disadvantage the
many. Just when the School system is giving unparallelled
scope for parental access and contribution to the syllabus,
should we be giving priority to a small group of children over
what can be done for the overwhelming majority. We must
remember that the coming of the Islamia primary school to
Brent, serving approximately 60 pupils seriously delayed, if
not permanently halted, all and any other muslim education
initiatives that might have been more relevant to the
approximately 10,000 muslim schoolchildren in that catchment
area.
As
opposed to the typical muslim approach, perhaps a school to
deal with the loss of muslim youth should be starting with
teenagers and working down. Then we would also know that we
are not just opening a primary school because it is apparently
easy, and hoping that by the time they are teenagers we will
have found a way to deal with the true nature of our childrens'
problem.
I
would suggest that there are four essential areas where work
must be done before we can provide a relevant Islamic
education, and make no apologies concerning bias in that two
of those are areas in which I am working myself:
Firstly,
research into the integration of Islamic knowledge through the
UK curriculum.
Secondly,
production of educational material for use within the UK
system, to suit both the English National Curriculum, and the
Scottish Curriculum. Work needs to be done in that area
immediately, as without curriculum work there can be no
integrated system. Without more Educational material, it will
not be possible to put that curriculum into teaching practice.
Thirdly,
without more translation of source texts, that teaching must
be severely limited in its range.
Fourthly,
without teacher training you have no qualified teachers and no
school.
Approach:
I
also think it is of crucial importance to consider whether we
have friendly or hostile relations with the system, examining
the practicalities of our minority situation, and deciding
whether we are to live in the culture that surrounds us as
explorers or as warriors behind enemy lines. For those who
wish to treat the situation as one of war, I seriously
recommend that they look carefully at the odds before they
sound the charge. Bluster wins few battles. Either way, I
would suggest that the language of confrontation is unlikely
to produce the desired results.
CONCLUSION
I
leave you with the end of the lecture with which I started.
It
is a truism to say that everybody wants to be loved, but more
than power and achievements it is the thing that gives
satisfaction to our beings. Wouldn't we all like to feel that
everyone we knew loved us, that they would give up all their
possessions for us, and that they would die to protect
us. Surrounded by friends like that would we not be satisfied
and happy.
So
whose example can we take as an example of this kind of life.
The example that muslims take was patient, honest, just and
chaste. He was the most generous of men, never asked for
anything but that he gave it to the asker. He would prefer the
seeker to himself and his family, and often went hungry
because of it. He patched his own sandals and clothing, and
did household chores. He was shy and would not stare into
peoples faces. He attended feasts and funerals, visited the
sick, and walked among enemies without a guard. He was the
humblest of men. He sat and ate with the poor. He tyrannized
nobody and accepted the excuse of anyone who begged his
pardon. He was always joyful and never awed by the affairs of
this world. He joked, but only spoke the truth. He did not eat
better food than his servants. He refused to curse his
enemies, saying "I was sent to forgive, not to
curse". When asked to wish evil on anyone he blessed them
instead. If there was a bed he slept on it, if not he reclined
on the earth. One did not argue in his presence. He spoke only
the truth. He was the most smiling and laughing of men.
His
companion Ali said "Of all men he was the most generous,
the most open-hearted, the most truthful, the most fulfilling
of promise, the gentlest of temper, and the noblest towards
his family. Whoever saw him unexpectedly was awed by him, and
whoever knew him intimately loved him." His answer to his
name was "At your service". His name was Muhammad.
Astaghfirallah
- I beg forgiveness of God for such mistakes as I have made.
The Truth belongs to God alone.
|