|
1988 saw the
publication of Salman Rushdie's 'The Satanic Verses', and in the
beginning, apart from the literary fanfare you might expect with the
publication of a new book by the author of 'Midnight's
Children', you wouldn't really have noticed anything much had
changed in the world, and certainly not in UK mosques, where the
Booker Prize will usually cause about as much stir as the
publication of the latest issue of an abstruse academic journal.
Months later, however, a previously insignificant author in an
almost unheard of and largely unread magazine for muslim readers
published an article that would fairly quickly change all that. The
author found Mr. Rushdie's book offensive and insulting, not to
himself personally you must understand, but an insult to the Prophet
and his wives and companions, an insult of which he had not doubt
and that he explained and illustrated in a somewhat inflammatory
manner for his readers using very brief selective extracts from the
book. Now clearly if what was said in the article was true the book
was highly inflammatory and seriously offensive to the muslim
community, and although Impact magazine may have had very few
readers, photocopies come cheap and the essentially offensive nature
of the book could soon be seen on walls and tables in mosques
(though the book had by now been reduced to its 'essence' on one A5
sheet of paper). But still it seemed insignificant really, almost
laughable, a source of wry amusement that here the muslims in the
mosques were at it again, getting worked up into a frenzy of
indignation about something they had clearly misunderstood, and
which had little relevance to their lives compared to so many things
that they chose to ignore. And then someone (I seem to remember
Kalim Siddiqui liked to take the credit) took it one stage further,
and disregarding matters of actual guilt inquired of the Ayatollah
Khomeini something like what was the sentence to be pronounced on an
apostate who now attacked the Prophet and his family with the
foulest of abuse, sacrilege, heresy and blasphemy, and the Ayatollah
naturally suggested the appropriate historical punishment as he
understood it, which was death.
Whereupon the effluent hit
the air conditioning, and the rest, as they say, is history.
Suddenly there was a bounty on Rushdie's head, and the media brought
the full weight of their dispassionate objectivity to bear on the
case, and every TV programme from the News to Kilroy's pontifichat
was gleefully fuelling the fire. Quite early in the proceedings,
long before I could get a copy of the rapidly sold-out book to read,
I was asked for my opinions on the BBC, but the wry amusement I had
felt at the start of the proceedings had long given way to a cold
horror at what was going on, and gentle words suggesting calm and
reappraisal didn't have quite the same newsworthy impact as those at
the Central Mosque who were telling the media that they would
personally thrust the knife into him if only they were given the
chance. But no-one was arrested for advocating murder (a big mistake
in my opinion - I promise you an arrest or two would have quietened
much of the bombast). I also gave a lecture or two about it at that
time (one I gave at Swansea University can be found here),
but matters already seemed to have got to the point where no-one
could actually believe that he hadn't said what everyone seemed to
be shouting so loudly that he had. And there were riots in Pakistan
and other places in which people died, and academics in Europe who
spoke out against what was going on got stabbed to death, and all
manner of febrile insanity was going on. Long before the 'War on
Terror' non-muslim friends told of their fears that women in burkas
might be hiding suicide bombs strapped to their bodies (why they
thought they would be walking around Sauchiehall Street armed and
waiting for the opportunity to blow up Salman Rushdie if they
happened to meet him I never could quite understand - but just as
now fear makes people crazy). And I kept waiting for some muslim
academic somewhere to explain to the masses that things were not
quite as they seemed, or some politician willing to make a name for
himself as a Sunni vanquisher of the Shi'a 'heretics' and challenge
the Ayatollahs. But no-one did. And as things just kept getting more
crazy I thought 'well, if no-one else is going to do anything to put
forward an alternative point of view, I guess I will have to do it
myself'.
So having managed to get a
copy of the book itself by now, in the spring of 1990 I sat and
wrote the Tyranny of Certainty. It took me three months, and by that
time things had only seemed to get worse rather than better, so at
that point I had to decide what to do. Fortunately, a friend in the
Education Department at Strathclyde Council felt they owed me a
favour and offered to furtively get a hundred or so copies printed
for me (it seems ridiculous to say it, but furtive felt like the
minimum necessary in the hostile atmosphere) for which I was truly
grateful as there was no way that I could have afforded the
photocopying, even if I had been able to find a commercial printer
prepared to take the risk. By this time I had myself become
seriously paranoid about challenging the situation, and not without
justification I fully believe. Indeed, even when writing these words
and thinking about putting something written sixteen years ago on
line, there is a certain hollow feeling in the pit of my stomach
which wonders if I am actually signing my own death warrant. There
are no Special Branch bodyguards outside my door as there were
outside Salman Rushdie's, and as is obvious the 'crazy muslim' meter
has gone well off the scale in recent years, and the justification
of 'guilt' is not even a consideration for some self-righteous
crazies before they pull the trigger. But I'm old enough now, and
I've had cancer and a heart attack, and if God wants to take me in
some brutal fashion I guess I'll have to face it. Hopefully not. I
would actually quite like to finish IZWAYZ before I go, and get to
make my Hajj, and maybe nowadays the crazies have got other things
on their minds. Or perhaps this will just vanish in the way it did
last time. For here we come to the part of the story that makes you
wonder if your paranoid fantasies are indeed just a part of some
great conspiracy theory. As I say, things were very scary at the
time. So scary in fact, that I went to extraordinary lengths to make
sure that nothing about what I had written could be traced back to
me. Latex gloves to avoid fingerprints, tap-water not spittle to
moisten the glue on the envelopes, stamps bought in England and the
loaded envelopes posted there as well. And so my alternative way of
seeing the book went out to everyone that I thought might be useful
in spreading the word, or that was in a position of power to do
something to change the situation.
So it was posted to all the
Conservative front-benchers and most of the Labour and Lib-Dem
shadow cabinets and a few of the more quirky politicians who one
might have expected to be more fearless than others, and all the
daily newspapers and all the magazines that I thought relevant (not
Football weekly and the like), and more than one person in every
television and radio company to cover not only news and current
affairs but also the people doing the chat shows, and it went to
every University Department of English as well as Departments of
Religious Studies, as well as the British Library and the Library of
the House of Commons, and each person it was sent to had a
personally addressed letter explaining what it was and how it might
be relevant to them. And finally I felt that I had done what I
could, and drove home and wondered about the morrow. I had no idea
what might happen, but I felt sure that it was strong enough a
statement that someone had to make something of it. After all, I had
given some serious ammunition to anyone who felt the inclination to
challenge some of the more loud mouthed muslims who were doing the
media rounds, and let's face it the tabloids can make a huge story
with virtually no ammunition at all, so one wondered what they would
make of this. Anyway, I finally rested from my labours and waited
for the outcome with baited breath. And then the strangest thing
happened. Absolutely nothing. Not a word in any newspaper or
magazine, or radio or TV programme. No questions in the House.
Nothing. It was as though I had posted all those envelopes into a
black hole, and things may have been personally scary before but the
silence that ensued quickly became scarily weird. It was hard to
believe that every single person on my mailing list had just glanced
at what I'd sent and just consigned it immediately to the bin. Could
it really have come across as the rantings of some deranged nutter
considering the context of those who were appearing on the chat
shows nearly every day? And having been so extraordinarily secretive
in getting the thing out there, it was not even as if I could make
any follow-up phone calls to anyone saying 'Did you get my letter?'.
So, a year or so of living in the madness and three months of
slaving over a hot keyboard had apparently come to absolutely
nothing and I had to just get back on with my life. I'd done what I
could and the only result was that things seemed even weirder than
they did before.
And then, I think about four
days later, there was a rather strange story on the news. Salman
Rushdie had met with a group of muslim clerics/leaders/whatevers in
the Central Mosque in London and it appeared that there might be
some kind of rapprochement, the format of which I don't recall
exactly, but I like to think might have had something to do with
what I'd had to say. It didn't last long. The atmosphere had
apparently gone too far over the edge for anyone to drag it back.
But he never did get assassinated, and eventually the powers that be
seem to have decided to let him off the hook, and he seems to get
out in public with comparative immunity from the death threats these
days, for which I am grateful. But in the years that followed, on
the few occasions that I have handed a muslim a copy of the Tyranny
of Certainty to read, it has almost invariably been returned to me
with a wordless gaze of what seems to be blank incomprehension that
such an overwhelmingly accepted truth is actually open to serious
challenge. The one muslim who had a different response was Zaki
Badawi (now dead, and a sad loss to us all) who was visiting our
house on one occasion, and when I handed it to
him glanced at it briefly, smiled and handed it back saying 'the
trouble with this is that it makes the muslims look like idiots',
which makes me think that just maybe he had come across it before. I suppose my answer to that
might have been 'but this was written by a muslim, and I don't think it comes across
as having been written by an idiot, and there are plenty of
non-idiot muslims in the world. Must they all keep quiet and let the
idiots do the talking?' Or I could have said 'surely the muslims
don't need me to make them look like idiots when they have made it
perfectly clear that they are more than capable of doing that for
themselves'. But in the event I didn't say either - I just laughed. Nowadays of course muslims living in the
west have different and more pressing issues that overwhelm most
others concerning their relationship with the societies in which
they live. And I may be unsure whether I had anything to contribute
to the Satanic Verses affair, but I have no doubt at all that the
global scale of the War on Terror is way beyond my scope, and we
will just have to trust that God knows best how He will shape the
future of mankind. As for me, I'll just keep on trying to finish
IZWAYZ in the hope that it can help a few muslim children living in
the west to come to terms with their surroundings and find a way of
living as muslims amidst the extraordinary changes to the world that
God has planned.
|
|